News
Interview: What Will Be THE Marine Fuel of the Future?
The International Maritime Organization (IMO) is standing its ground on the implementation of the 2020 Sulfur Cap having reaffirmed its position that there is no turning back with regard to the implementation date.
Nevertheless, ship owners and operators are faced with a number of worries when it comes to adhering to the new rules and investing in compliant technology. In fact, many companies are adopting the “wait and see“ approach.
World Maritime News spoke with Dr. Marc Perrin, Independent Consultant for ENGIE Lab CRIGEN and Olivier Jouny, Managing Director, Total Marine Fuels Global Solutions, during Asia Pacific Maritime on the current state of play in relation to the industry’s preparedness for the new rules and the most economically viable option when picking a compliant fuel.
There are several ways to get ready for the 2020 Sulfur Cap. Among the options on the table are low sulfur heavy fuel oil (HFO), marine gas oil (MGO), Exhaust Gas Treatment (scrubbers) or other alternative fuels, such as LNG, hydrogen, etc.
However, the capacity of refineries to produce a sufficient amount of low sulfur fuel oil (LSFO) for ships in time has been brought to question. On the other hand, opting for scrubbers results in other issues such as space availability, vessel stability and higher operating costs, to name just a few.
“Right after the IMO announced that the deadline would be 2020 we decided to reorganize our bunkering business and position ourselves as a global solutions provider, and not just only a product supplier. In some parts of the world, the availability of LSFO can indeed be questioned. However, as an integrated group with strong assets all along the oil chain, we are currently working with our refining and trading teams and we will be able to supply our customers with 0.5 percent sulfur fuel oil in the main hubs,” Jouny said.
To LNG or not to LNG?
According to Perrin, there is only one option that is already available worldwide as a utility product and that is compliant with actual and upcoming emissions limitations.
“Indeed, lots of efforts still remain to be put in, mostly regarding investments in LNG bunkering facilities, however, LNG as a fuel is already available in most major ports and areas impacted by emissions regulations. In the most optimistic forecasts for the development of LNG as marine fuel, this specific market will represent only a few percent of the global LNG world market. So there is no global availability issue for LNG with large reserves being explored, contrarily to its competitor fuels such as LPG or methanol. And there is a good reason to think that the LNG price will probably remain low for the years to come,” he said.
Perrin believes that an encouraging trend can be seen with regard to the uptake of LNG as marine fuel over the past few years.
“In February 2018, 122 LNG-fuelled marine ships were being built or sailing and 143 vessels were on order. That represents a very rapid growth considering that four years ago, in 2014, there were 56 LNG vessels, that’s less than 50 percent of actual numbers,” he added.
CMA CGM’s decision to order nine mega LNG-fueled containerships sent a strong signal to the industry, Jouny said.
“Major shipping companies, who previously did not show great interest in LNG, are now starting to review their position and are asking us to help them reassess the case. With the recent LNG bunker supply contracts we signed with Brittany Ferries and CMA CGM, we proved that we were both strongly supporting the use of LNG as a marine fuel and that we were able to provide dedicated logistics and tailor-made solutions to our customers. We do believe that the development of logistical solutions in different ports to enlarge the network will help the development of LNG bunkering,” Jouny further noted.
LPG an alternative to LNG?
Several industry players have identified LPG as a much more cost-effective alternative to LNG, which is easier to implement in practice. However, Perrin believes that LPG is not really an alternative to LNG for many reasons.
The primary argument for this rests on the limited quantities of LPG and its dependence on other industries for production, as compared to LNG which intrinsically has fuel applications.
“Secondly, LPG emits more CO2 and NOx than LNG. Thirdly, the logistic issue is not trivial and similar in complexity and cost to the LNG one. And today the main market for LPG is the use as a feedstock in the chemical industry. Last but not least, marine gas engines are designed mainly for natural gas (CNG or LNG) that is easier to burn in engines than LPG. Therefore, for all of these reasons, I don’t anticipate a fast development of LPG as a marine fuel as is the actual case for LNG,” he explained.
Jouny further added that LPG is not such a cost-effective solution, with prices being more volatile than for LNG as they are impacted by both crude prices and a seasonality effect. Moreover, the infrastructure is not adequately developed. What is more, investments to equip vessels with systems able to run on LPG are significant and safety issues are a real concern, he pointed out.
What about methanol?
Methanol has emerged as a potential alternative to LNG and LPG, but it remains in the shadows of more competitive fuels.
Namely, methanol is mainly produced from biomass, which means that it is produced in small quantities when compared to the global marine market needs.
“From a safety standpoint, methanol is toxic and with vapors denser than air, the risk of intoxication by inhalation or skin contact is high,” Perrin stressed. “In addition, methanol flame is not in the visible range.”
From a technical standpoint, the engine still needs some modifications before being able to burn this fuel, especially in respect to the risk of corrosion for the engine and the piping system and fuel tanks, Perrin continued.
Hence, the conclusion is that there is a lack of maturity in methanol engine technologies.
“Methanol has a lower energy content per unit volume than conventional fuels and LNG and requires larger onboard storage space,” Perrin said.
Speaking on the potential disadvantages of methanol as marine fuel, Jouny said that its price is not competitive with that of conventional fuel or LNG.
“The production of biomethanol will play an important role in developing methanol as a fuel since it will strongly reduce the CO2 impact. However, for the moment, this is not competitive,” he explained.
“The rise in Brent prices and the impact of the global gap on MGO prices could boost the sector from 2019. However, today, the potential customers of methanol as a marine fuel remain the shortsea vessels sailing in the ECA zone,” Jouny said.
Where to invest?
As ship owners are long-term investors, LNG is really the right investment to be made, according to Perrin.
The availability of LNG and its environmental benefits have been identified as key benefits for owners. In addition, technological innovations and progress are boosting the competitiveness of LNG as compared to conventional fuels.
“This supports and boosts engineering companies, ship owners and operators, bunkering operators, in mastering this new fuel: innovative storage technologies, boil-off gas management tools (LNG Master, Smart LNG Gauge), LNG quality for engine assessment (new PKI methodology for calculating Methane Number),” Perrin said.
“So for these reasons, when it comes to investing for a couple of decades into a fleet, then definitely LNG is THE fuel of choice,” he pointed out.
Source: www.worldmaritimenews.com
Other News by Category
General Shipping & Maritime
-
Port of Rotterdam Reports Success in Bunker Spill Cleanup
-
Day of the Seafarer: Mental Wellbeing in Focus
-
Posidonia 2018: 5 Most Exciting Things to Watch Out for in Shipping Industry
-
North Korea's High-Seas Fuel Smuggling Continues
-
Meyer Turku hands over new-design Mein Schiff 1
-
92% Of Seafarers Strongly Influenced By Internet Access – Futurenautics
-
Container ship MSC Kia Ora banned from Australian ports
-
Carnival to increase capacity on short cruise program with arrival of Carnival Dream in 2019
-
LNG cruise ships herald new era of training
-
Kinder Morgan takes delivery of 4th tanker from Philly Shipyard
Safety & Piracy
-
Three Killed, Five Missing After Two Ships Collide Near Shanghai
-
Oil tanker hit by blast at Saudi terminal, Saudi Arabia confirms
-
AMSA To End Permit That Allowed Seafarers To Work Longer Than 11 Months On Board Ships
-
Pirates Kidnap 19 in Two Separate Incidents in Gulf of Guinea -Dryad
-
ONE Containership Diverted to Tacoma Due to Collapsed Containers
-
Container Incident in Bristol Channel
-
Australia Evacuates Crew from Coronavirus-hit Livestock Carrier
-
Here’s One Way To Avoid COVID19 – Set Your Ship Adrift In Arctic Ice
-
Containership with Cracked Hull Leaking Fuel Oil in Bayonne, NJ
-
ICS, UNHCR and IOM call on States to end humanitarian crisis onboard ship in the Mediterranean
Maritime Economy
-
Port of Long Beach Reports Busiest Year in 2020 Despite Headwinds
-
MSC Joins Hydrogen Council To Collaborate On Decarbonisation
-
Could Flow Battery Technology Help Shipping Decarbonize?
-
Oil Has Best Week in Four Months With Saudi Cut Buoying Prices
-
China issues five million tonne clean marine fuel export quotas for 2021: traders
-
Growth in the LNG Bunker Vessel Fleet
-
Maersk Elba loses power after fire off Portugal
-
U.S. Congress Approves Funds for Fourth National Security Multi-Mission Vessel
-
‘Matsonia’ Delivered to Matson, Completing Hawaii Fleet Renewal
-
Qatar Condemns Attack on Oil Tanker in Saudi Port of Jeddah
Environment & Technology
-
A.P. Moller- Maersk, The Ocean Cleanup extend relationship with new three-year partnership
-
Top charterers agree to publish shipping emissions data
-
MSC Sees Hydrogen And Biofuels As Key Components Of Shipping’s Future Fuel Mix
-
Storm-weary U.S. energy producers, refiners prep for hurricane strike
-
In Just 20 Years, Ships Could Cross an Open Arctic Ocean
-
As Arctic Ice Melts, Polluting Ships Stream Into Polar Waters
-
Hapag-Lloyd to lower CO2 emissions using biofuel
-
GLOBAL: NEW REPORT CLAIMS LNG AS MARINE FUEL IS ‘WORSE THAN BUSINESS AS USUAL FOR THE CLIMATE’
-
Study: New Blends of Marine Fuels Have Higher BC Emissions than HFO
-
New Report Identifies Clean Energy Options for Global Shipping Industry
Offshore, Oil & Gas
-
Rise in New Southeast Asia Upstream Players
-
Iraq looks to rebuild tanker fleet, eyes crude oil sales on delivered basis
-
Interview: Methanol Is Ready for Use as Marine Fuel
-
Chevron Announces Gorgon Expansion
-
Interview: What Will Be THE Marine Fuel of the Future?
-
Skangas Celebrates Milestone with 1,000 LNG Bunkering Operations in 2017
-
New LNG Carrier Design Suits “Milk Run”
-
Japan Commissions Oil Tanker To Combat Chinese Presence In East China Sea
-
Danish Energy Agency Clears Maersk Oil Sale
-
Offshore architects diversify and look to new roles for existing designs
Port & Shipbuilding
-
Bulk Shipping Comes Back to Oakland Port
-
Port of Newcastle to become the first Australian port to join the International EcoPorts network
-
CSP Abu Dhabi Terminal opens at Khalifa Port
-
North Sea Port: We Are Ready to Invest in Hydrogen as Fuel
-
Port Awarded $50 Million for Zero Emissions Project
-
New container terminal planned for Port of Newcastle
-
Port of Gothenburg Adds LNG Bunkering Option
-
China’s conquest of European box ports
-
Damen acquires Daewoo’s Mangalia yard
-
ICTSI approves Iraq’s BGT development
Events & Press Releases
-
Nakilat records 13% increased profits for the first quarter of 2018
-
Cargo throughput of UCL Holding’s stevedoring division rises 9% to 37.1 million tonnes
-
International Sea Ports and Maritime Authorities Gather in 2 Weeks to Discuss Port Security Technology
-
Hydropower Balkans 2017
-
Hydropower Balkans 2017 - Free Webinar
-
Speaker Line Up is Announced for the Maritime Big Data Forum at Nor-Shipping on 30 May
-
Sea Asia 2017 Reinforces Role as Leading Maritime Forum in Southeast Asia
-
10th International Fujairah Bunkering & Fuel Oil Forum: Event Summary
-
Counter-Terrorism Measures at Ports
-
DHT Holdings, Inc. announces delivery of first VLCC from BW Group
National (Croatian)
-
Uljanik plovidba ulazi na tržište prijevoza ukapljenog plina
-
Hrvatska brodogradnja - poslovi vrijedni 1,9 milijardi dolara
-
Zanimanje po kojem je Hrvatska oduvijek bila poznata u svijetu potrebno je spašavati od izumiranja
-
Drama u Arapskom moru: Naš tanker iz Uljanika napali pirati
-
Luka Rijeka planira od ulagača privući 300 milijuna kuna
-
Uljaniku i »3. maju« gradnja 20 brodova u idućih 15 godina
-
Floti Jadrolinije priključen brod „Mljet“
-
Jadroliniji prijete tužbe teške 20 milijuna kuna
-
U lovu na konkurente: Rijeka raste, ali promet luke u Kopru i dalje je četiri puta veći
-
Treća novogradnja u seriji, brod „Krk“ svečano priključen floti Jadrolinije